ILC DC#26111
By Dr. Roderick J. Glatt
A recent proposal in Tennessee to expand alternative pathways to teacher licensure has reignited an important conversation among educators, policymakers, parents, and school leaders. At the center of the discussion is a question that deserves thoughtful consideration rather than emotional reaction: Does passing the Praxis make someone a better teacher? While teacher licensure examinations were designed to help establish minimum standards for entering the profession, many educators argue that standardized testing alone cannot fully measure the knowledge, instructional skill, and relational capacity required to positively impact students. This conversation presents an opportunity to examine what research says about the characteristics of truly effective teaching.
What is the purpose of the Praxis examination?
The Praxis examination was developed to assess a prospective teacher's content knowledge and, in some cases, pedagogical understanding before entering the classroom. Many states have adopted the assessment as one component of teacher licensure because it provides a common measure across candidates from different universities and preparation programs. Supporters believe the examination helps protect instructional quality by ensuring teachers possess foundational academic knowledge in their subject areas. While these goals are reasonable, passing a standardized examination should be viewed as the beginning of professional readiness rather than definitive evidence of classroom effectiveness.
Does passing the Praxis automatically produce highly effective teachers?
Passing the Praxis demonstrates that an individual has met a minimum academic benchmark, but it does not automatically predict instructional excellence. Every experienced school leader has observed teachers who performed exceptionally well on certification examinations yet struggled to build relationships, manage classrooms, or accelerate student learning. Conversely, many outstanding educators who initially struggled with standardized testing have consistently demonstrated remarkable instructional effectiveness and produced exceptional academic outcomes for students. Effective teaching requires the successful integration of content knowledge, communication, classroom management, instructional decision-making, adaptability, and genuine care for learners.
What does research identify as the strongest predictors of teacher effectiveness?
Educational research consistently demonstrates that effective teaching extends far beyond standardized test performance. Classroom observations, instructional coaching, strong school leadership, ongoing professional learning, meaningful feedback, and reflective practice contribute significantly to teacher growth and student achievement. Researchers such as John Hattie, Linda Darling-Hammond, and Robert Marzano emphasize that teacher effectiveness develops through continuous improvement supported by high-quality leadership and collaborative professional cultures. The most accomplished educators are distinguished not simply by what they know but by how successfully they translate that knowledge into meaningful learning experiences for every student.
How should Tennessee approach alternative pathways to teacher licensure?
Alternative pathways should neither lower expectations nor weaken professional standards. Instead, they should expand opportunities for talented individuals while maintaining rigorous measures of classroom performance, instructional competence, and professional growth. Candidates who enter through alternative routes should receive intensive mentoring, frequent instructional coaching, structured classroom observations, and demonstrated evidence of student learning before earning long-term professional status. Expanding access to the profession should never mean reducing accountability for instructional excellence.
What should ultimately determine whether someone becomes a licensed teacher?
The ultimate measure of a teacher should be sustained effectiveness in the classroom rather than performance on a single examination. A balanced licensure system should recognize the value of academic preparation while also giving significant weight to instructional practice, professional dispositions, classroom management, student engagement, and measurable academic growth. Schools exist to improve student learning, and every component of teacher licensure should support that mission. The strongest educational systems maintain high standards while recognizing that outstanding teaching is demonstrated daily through the success of students rather than by a single testing event.
Bottom Line Educational Solution
The current Tennessee discussion provides an opportunity to rethink how teacher quality is measured without diminishing the importance of professional standards. Passing the Praxis should remain one valuable indicator of readiness, but it should not be considered the sole predictor of long-term teacher effectiveness. School leaders, preparation programs, and state policymakers should work together to develop licensure systems that evaluate both academic competence and demonstrated instructional performance. When licensure reflects what truly matters inside the classroom, students, teachers, and schools all benefit.
Key Principle
Teacher effectiveness is ultimately demonstrated by consistent student learning, professional practice, and instructional excellence—not by a single standardized examination.
References
Darling-Hammond, L. (2006). Powerful Teacher Education: Lessons from Exemplary Programs. Jossey-Bass.
Darling-Hammond, L. (2017). Empowered Educators: How High-Performing Systems Shape Teaching Quality Around the World. Jossey-Bass.
Fullan, M. (2020). Leading in a Culture of Change (2nd ed.). Jossey-Bass.
Hattie, J. (2023). Visible Learning: The Sequel. Routledge.
Marzano, R. J. (2017). The New Art and Science of Teaching. Solution Tree Press.
Whitaker, T. (2013). The Principal: Three Keys to Maximizing Impact. Routledge.
____________________
Roderick J. Glatt, Ed.D. | Educational Consultant (K–12)
Dr. Glatt serves as Lower School Principal (K–8) and Associate Principal of Student Affairs (K–12) at Ezell-Harding Christian School. He previously served in Metro Nashville Public Schools as a classroom discipline and behavioral practitioner supporting grades 6–8 and 9–12 student behavior systems and instructional culture. Through Innovative Leadership Consulting, he partners with educators and school leaders to implement evidence-based practices that strengthen classroom management, improve school culture, and increase academic rigor.




