What has stepping away from publishing helped me see more clearly?

Over the past several months, I stepped away from my regular publishing schedule while settling into a new school leadership role. My days have been filled with listening, assessing existing systems, supporting teachers, and responding to students who need direction. As my responsibilities have shifted toward student culture across grades K–12, one conviction has become clearer: the conditions surrounding teaching deserve as much intentional attention as the lessons themselves. I am returning to this space with renewed purpose—to offer teachers and leaders encouragement they can use and practical direction they can put to work. November is an opportunity to pause, take stock, and prepare a stronger foundation for the months ahead.

What do students experience when expectations change from room to room?

Consider a student moving through a school day: entering a classroom, asking for help, joining a discussion, transitioning into the hallway, and beginning independent work. Each moment carries expectations. When those expectations are left unstated, students must guess what success looks like. Shared language gives adults and students a reference point. That does not require every classroom to operate identically. A kindergarten room and a high school laboratory have different needs. It does mean that expectations should be understandable, appropriate to the setting, and explicitly taught. Before asking whether students followed a procedure, we should ask whether we made that procedure clear enough to practice. The Education Endowment Foundation (2019) recommends a consistent schoolwide approach alongside classroom management training and an understanding of individual students’ needs. Shared expectations should therefore provide a dependable foundation while allowing tailored support for students who need it.

Can a classroom expectation become a habit simply because it is posted?

A well-designed sign can make an expectation visible. Teaching makes its meaning usable. In its 2024 guide for grades K–5, the What Works Clearinghouse assigns strong evidence to jointly establishing, modeling, and teaching behavior expectations that align with schoolwide expectations. It also identifies strong evidence for reminders and positive acknowledgment of expected behavior (What Works Clearinghouse, 2024). These recommendations support an active teaching process. A volume-level display, for example, becomes more useful when a teacher demonstrates the appropriate level for a task, lets students practice, and offers specific feedback. The guide addresses K–5; applying similar ideas in later grades requires attention to students’ age and context, rather than assuming the same research directly covers every grade.

Which routines deserve our attention first?

Start with one moment that repeatedly interrupts the learning day. Perhaps students lose direction while gathering materials. Perhaps a transition begins before anyone knows where to go. Perhaps requests for help compete with instruction. Select one routine, describe its steps, model it, and give students an opportunity to rehearse. If hand signals are part of your school’s approach, explain their meanings and provide accessible alternatives when needed. If voice levels are displayed, connect them to actual tasks. My recommendation is to begin with a routine you can observe and revisit, then build from there. A manageable improvement is easier to sustain than a long list of expectations introduced at once.

How can leaders make consistency a shared responsibility?

Leaders can begin by entering classrooms with curiosity: What is working? Which transition needs support? What would make this expectation easier to teach? A productive visit should lead to a specific next step and a return conversation. Teachers need usable materials, time to teach routines, and dependable follow-through from the adults around them. Shared signage can reinforce that effort, particularly when the language is consistent across common spaces. Yet professional judgment still matters. Consistency should allow for developmental differences, individual needs, and reasonable adjustments. The leadership task is to build shared understanding while helping teachers make the practices work in their own classrooms. Research also supports sustained coaching. In a meta-analysis of 60 studies using causal research designs, Kraft et al. (2018) found average effects of 0.49 standard deviations on instructional practice and 0.18 on student achievement. Much of the evidence concerned literacy coaching in prekindergarten and elementary settings, and effects were smaller in larger programs. These findings support investing in coaching while attending carefully to its quality and context; they do not establish the effect of the specific routine proposed here.

What do the numbers tell us about protecting teaching time?

National data show why this work deserves attention. The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES, 2023) reported that 32 percent of public school teachers in 2020–21 agreed that student misbehavior interfered with their teaching. Separately, 37 percent agreed that tardiness and class cutting interfered with teaching. These are teacher-reported survey findings from public schools during a pandemic-era school year. They are not measurements of conditions at my school, and they do not establish that signage or any single routine will resolve the problem. They do provide a reason to examine how the learning day is organized. Leaders should combine broader research with local observations before choosing an approach or claiming improvement.

What can we strengthen before January arrives?

November and December offer a practical window for reviewing the routines we want students to carry into the new year. A teacher might select one transition and record how long it takes across several days. A leader might ask a team whether students receive the same explanation of a shared hallway expectation. Together, they can identify a starting point, teach the practice, and revisit what happens. Shorter transitions should also remain safe and accessible; speed alone is an incomplete measure of success. My own focus is to work classroom by classroom, listening and helping establish clear, age-appropriate practices. The goal is a January start built on preparation and shared understanding.

What is one step a teacher and a leader can take this week?

For teachers, choose one routine that needs clarification and teach it as deliberately as a new academic skill: explain, demonstrate, practice, and provide feedback. For leaders, ask one teacher which routine would benefit most from your support, then agree on a practical action and a follow-up date. Use the same question with students: Can you explain what is expected and show what it looks like? Their responses can reveal where our instruction needs greater clarity. If you are looking for a starting point for personal reflection, explore MyClassroomPulse™ through Innovative Leadership Consulting. Use that reflection to identify a focused area for growth and a meaningful coaching conversation.

Bottom Line Educational Solution

As we enter a season associated with gratitude, we can express appreciation for teachers through practical support. We can protect time to teach expectations, provide clear materials, and return to help when a routine needs adjustment. Students benefit from adults who explain expectations and respond with patience and consistency. Teachers deserve partners who help make that work manageable. This week, choose one routine, strengthen how it is taught, and notice what students show you. Shared expectations become part of a school’s culture through the daily actions of the people who teach and practice them.

Key Principle: An expectation becomes part of a learning culture when it is understood, practiced, and consistently supported.

References